Eye Makeup

Paint yer lids and coat yer lashes in vibrant pigments and holo glitter at Tragic Beautiful! We stock highly pigmented and quality eye makeup built to last thru the night n’ day from popular brands Lime Crime, Manic Panic, Mermaid Salon, Evil Eye Cosmetics, Drop Dead Gorgeous and Deadly Sins Cosmetics. Keep the tradgoth vibes alive with pitch-black liner or change it up with versatile shadow palettes oozing pastel goth n’ cyber goth vibes. Best of all? Every brand we stock is totally vegan and cruelty-free!

What We’ve Got: Eyeshadow pans, eyeshadow palettes, eyebrow pomade, liquid eyeliner, kohl eyeliner, eyeshadow primer, glitter, mascara.

Filters

Eyeshadow Palettes
Fake Eyelashes
Eyeliner
Eye Makeup
Eyebrows
$
to
$
Sort by
Time to Unwind Chamomile Makeup RemoverTime to Unwind Chamomile Makeup Remover
ADD TO CART
Bloom Face SkincareTime to Unwind Chamomile Makeup Remover
$16.95
Cathedral Glass Eyeshadow PaletteCathedral Glass Eyeshadow Palette
ADD TO CART
Mermaid SalonCathedral Glass Eyeshadow Palette
$39.95
Dark Fairy Tale Eyeshadow PaletteDark Fairy Tale Eyeshadow Palette
ADD TO CART
Mermaid SalonDark Fairy Tale Eyeshadow Palette
$39.95
Jelly Baby Crystal Eyes Kit-Mermaid Salon-Tragic BeautifulJelly Baby Crystal Eyes Kit-Mermaid Salon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Mermaid SalonJelly Baby Crystal Eyes Kit
$38.95
Coffin Lashes | Midsommar-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulCoffin Lashes | Midsommar-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousCoffin Lashes | Midsommar
$19.95
Coffin Lashes | Blue Moon-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulCoffin Lashes | Blue Moon-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousCoffin Lashes | Blue Moon
$19.95
Coffin Lashes | Grey Ghost-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulCoffin Lashes | Grey Ghost-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousCoffin Lashes | Grey Ghost
$19.95
Coffin Lashes | Fluffy Moth-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulCoffin Lashes | Fluffy Moth-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousCoffin Lashes | Fluffy Moth
$19.95
Drag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Blue-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Blue-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Blue
$22.95
Drag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Purple-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Purple-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Purple
$22.95
Drag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Black-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic BeautifulDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Black-Drop Dead Gorgeous-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousDrag Me To Hell Rhinestone Lash Pack | Black
$22.95
Colour Flare Lashes | Belladonna-Rose Demon-Tragic BeautifulColour Flare Lashes | Belladonna-Rose Demon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousColour Flare Lashes | Belladonna
$16.95
Colour Flare Lashes | Empress Eerie-Rose Demon-Tragic BeautifulColour Flare Lashes | Empress Eerie-Rose Demon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousColour Flare Lashes | Empress Eerie
$16.95
Colour Flare Lashes | Pink Spectre-Rose Demon-Tragic BeautifulColour Flare Lashes | Pink Spectre-Rose Demon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousColour Flare Lashes | Pink Spectre
$16.95
Colour Flare Lashes | Rose Ruin-Rose Demon-Tragic BeautifulColour Flare Lashes | Rose Ruin-Rose Demon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Drop Dead GorgeousColour Flare Lashes | Rose Ruin
$16.95
Ocean Potion Makeup Transformer & Adhesive-Mermaid Salon-Tragic BeautifulOcean Potion Makeup Transformer & Adhesive-Mermaid Salon-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Mermaid SalonOcean Potion Makeup Transformer & Adhesive
$18.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Falling | Black-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Falling | Black-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Falling | Black
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Dreaming | Dusky Pink Nude-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Dreaming | Dusky Pink Nude-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Dreaming | Dusky Pink Nude
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Bitten | Flame Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Bitten | Flame Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Bitten | Flame Red
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Corruption | Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Corruption | Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Corruption | Red
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Blooded | Bright Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Blooded | Bright Red-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Blooded | Bright Red
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Hallowed | Light Brown-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Hallowed | Light Brown-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Hallowed | Light Brown
$13.95
Eye & Lip Liner Pencil | Fleeting | Dusty Rose-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic BeautifulEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Fleeting | Dusty Rose-Evil Eye Cosmetics-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Evil Eye CosmeticsEye & Lip Liner Pencil | Fleeting | Dusty Rose
$13.95
Underworld Eyeshadow Palette-Burn Book Inc-Tragic BeautifulUnderworld Eyeshadow Palette-Burn Book Inc-Tragic Beautiful
ADD TO CART
Burn Book IncUnderworld Eyeshadow Palette
$35.95

Gothic Eye Makeup, Eyeshadow Palettes & More

Eyes hold the power to captivate and mesmerize, and at Tragic Beautiful, we believe in embracing the dark allure of gothic beauty. Explore our extensive collection of eye makeup, featuring the best products from popular alternative brands like Lime Crime, Manic Panic, Deadly Sins, Evil Eye Cosmetics, Mermaid Salon, and more. Whether you're looking for gothic eyeliner, dark eyeshadows, or dramatic false lashes, we've got everything you need to create eye-catching looks that reflect your unique style.

Gothic Eyeliner & Eyeshadow

Line your eyes with precision and intensity using our selection of liquid and gel eyeliners, available in a variety of shades to suit any mood or occasion. From classic jet black to a rainbow of hues, our eyeliners can take your everyday makeup routine to new heights or add the perfect touch of drama to your evening looks.

Discover the iconic Venus Grunge eyeshadow palettes that have won the hearts of gothic beauty gurus worldwide. These palettes feature smudge-proof and pigmented shades in a range of shimmers, glitters, and soft mattes, allowing you to create endless eye-catching looks that express your individuality.

Vegan False Lashes For Eye Popping Looks

Enhance your gaze with our collection of vegan false lashes that offer dramatic volume and flair. Whether you're hitting the party scene or adding a touch of glam to your everyday look, our false lashes provide the perfect finishing touch to your eye makeup.

Cruelty-Free & Vegan Beauty Supplies

At Tragic Beautiful, we are committed to sustainability and ethical practices. That's why we refuse to stock any cosmetics that have been tested on animals. All our eye makeup and beauty supplies are cruelty-free and vegan, allowing you to embrace your gothic beauty with a clear conscience.

Create captivating eye makeup looks with our wide range of gothic eyeliners, dark eyeshadows, and other eye makeup essentials. From bold and daring to subtly enchanting, our collection caters to all your alternative beauty needs. Embrace the power of your eyes and let your gothic allure shine through with our cruelty-free and vegan eye makeup selection.